Orthoses
Night-time orthosis for clubfoot: after relapse following Ponseti, incomplete correction or late presentation
Ponseti is the gold standard for clubfoot, but the foot tends to relapse if bracing is wrong or too short. This article summarises the research on the ankle, knee and hip, Achilles re-tightening, which braces really reduce relapse – and introduces a custom night-time orthosis for each leg that corrects gradually while the child sleeps.
The Ponseti method (serial manipulation and casting, percutaneous Achilles tenotomy, then a foot abduction brace until 4–5 years) corrects most clubfeet without major surgery and is the gold standard. Its steps are described in detail in the article “Clubfoot and the Ponseti method” on this site.
This article focuses on what parents ask most after casting: how a child’s foot, knee and hip differ from other children after Ponseti; why clubfoot relapses and the Achilles tendon tightens again; which braces really reduce relapse; and the clinic’s night-time orthosis for children who relapse, are incompletely corrected or present late. Every figure has a source; the references link to PubMed.
Quick summary
- Ankle (strong evidence – meta-analysis): after Ponseti children push off more weakly, have a smaller ankle range of motion and more in-toeing than healthy children.
- Knee and hip: changes are mainly compensatory; in relapsed clubfoot, compensatory external hip rotation is found in 50–70% of limbs.
- Non-compliance with bracing is the main cause of relapse (86% of relapsed feet in a series of 115 feet); recurrent equinus (Achilles tightening) is the most common type of relapse.
- A standard ankle-foot orthosis (AFO) that only holds the foot straight: 83% relapse, versus 31% with a foot abduction brace (Janicki 2011).
- The clinic’s night-time orthosis: a separate custom brace for each leg, correcting step by step while the child sleeps, locking the heel to keep the ankle at 90° or more, with no bar between the legs. It is a new method; data are being collected.
1. After Ponseti: ankle, knee and hip
Ankle – strong evidence: the meta-analysis of 20 studies by Grin and colleagues (Children 2023) found several gait differences between Ponseti-treated and healthy children, most clearly at the ankle (less plantarflexion at push-off, smaller range of motion) and more in-toeing. Karol and colleagues (Clin Orthop Relat Res 2009), following children to age 5, found in-toeing in about one third of feet and lower ankle push-off power than normal; feet that kept their correction without surgery walked better than operated feet.
Put simply: the ankle is a weaker “spring”; when it pushes weakly and the foot points inwards, the knee and hip have to “work harder” to compensate. Clubfoot itself is also associated with increased internal hip rotation (Clin Orthop Relat Res 2009), so not every hip change is caused by treatment.
2. Do casts and braces harm the knee or hip?
Ponseti casts extend from the toes to the groin with the knee bent about 90° so that the leg cannot rotate inside the cast and the cast does not slip. Reported side effects are mainly skin-related: a Thai series (J Med Assoc Thai 2016) recorded a 17.8% complication rate with Ponseti casting, most often cast loosening (5.48%) and cast-related skin irritation (5.48%).
The foot abduction brace (two shoes joined by a bar) deliberately transmits external rotation through the tibia and femur to the knee and hip – that is part of treatment. In unilateral clubfoot the healthy foot also wears the brace and may become flat during this period (Medicine 2017). No large study has shown that Ponseti casts or braces cause lasting damage to the knee or hip; but there are also no studies following children into adulthood – absence of evidence is not proof of no harm.
3. Why does clubfoot relapse and the Achilles tendon tighten again?
After tenotomy the Achilles tendon heals at a new length, but the clubfoot tends to “pull back” to its old position. The foot abduction brace has built-in dorsiflexion to keep stretching the calf and tendon. If the heel slips out of the shoe or the child does not wear the brace long enough, the tendon loses this stretch and gradually shortens – the foot points down again (recurrent equinus).
| Finding | Data | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Non-compliance with bracing is the main cause of relapse | 86% of relapsed feet (99/115); equinus was the most common component of relapse | J Child Orthop 2018 |
| Longer foot abduction bracing reduces surgery | 279 feet: 12.9% needed further surgery; bracing duration was the most influential factor | Shabtai, J Child Orthop 2015 |
| Children treated after walking age | 429 feet: Ponseti corrected 87%, but 31% relapsed (mainly due to non-compliance) | Iowa Orthop J 2020 |
| Children aged 1–10 years | About 31% relapsed and needed further treatment | J Pediatr Orthop B 2019 |
Early warning signs: after removing the brace the heel has not touched the sole, or the foot keeps slipping out of the shoe – arrange a check-up. A foot that cannot dorsiflex enough slips out of the brace more easily, creating a vicious circle.
4. After relapse: a chain of compensation from foot to hip
Three-dimensional gait analysis in relapsed clubfoot shows a chain of changes from the bottom up:
| Level | Change in relapse | Frequency | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Foot | In-toeing | 73–80% | Graf 2009; Gait Posture 2020 |
| Foot | Supination in stance from an overactive tibialis anterior | 70% of supinated feet | Graf 2009 |
| Ankle | Reduced push-off (plantarflexion moment) | 83–84% | Gait Posture 2020 |
| Lower leg | Internal tibial torsion | 71% | Graf 2009 |
| Hip | Compensatory external rotation | 50–69% | Graf 2009; Gait Posture 2020 |
How to read the table: each figure is the percentage of feet or limbs with that change among children with relapsed clubfoot. When the foot and lower leg turn inwards, the body “corrects” by rotating the whole thigh outwards at the hip – the foot looks straighter but the hip is working unnaturally. Graf and colleagues (Clin Orthop Relat Res 2009) stress that this compensation is often invisible to the eye and only detected by gait analysis; in their study gait analysis changed the surgical plan in 63% of children.
Why avoid surgery at this stage: older children with relapse often need open Achilles lengthening, tendon transfer and sometimes bone surgery; major surgery is associated with stiffness and pain in adulthood. The sequence supported by the literature is repeat Ponseti casting (even in older children) → tenotomy if needed → maintenance bracing → surgery only if bracing cannot hold the correction.
5. Which braces really reduce relapse?
| Brace | Result | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Standard ankle-foot orthosis (AFO) holding the foot straight | Relapse needing further treatment 83% (25/30) vs 31% (12/39) with a foot abduction brace | Janicki, J Bone Joint Surg Br 2011 |
| Dynamic unilateral knee-ankle-foot orthosis with torsion (DTKAFO) | 88% compliance; 8% relapse at 2 years | Farrar, J Rehabil Assist Technol Eng 2022 |
| Custom unilateral lower-leg orthosis (LLO) | Compliance 91% vs 46% with the foot abduction brace; switching to the LLO at any time did not increase the surgery rate | BMC Musculoskelet Disord 2018 |
How to read the table: a standard AFO only holds the foot in a neutral position and does not provide the abduction and dorsiflexion needed to stretch the medial soft tissues – hence the high relapse rate. The review by Desai and colleagues (Iowa Orthop J 2010) stresses that adherence to bracing is the main factor in long-term success; new brace designs mostly aim to improve comfort so that children wear them long enough, but evidence on the clinical effect of each design is limited – and about 80% of children with clubfoot live in resource-limited countries, so cost and access matter too. Successful braces share features: they actively push the foot into abduction and dorsiflexion, include support above a flexed knee when tibial torsion needs correcting, and are tolerated long enough. Evidence gap: no large randomized trial has compared brace types in relapsed or late-presenting clubfoot; most data come from small studies.
6. The clinic’s night-time orthosis
Principle: like the hands of the clinician in the Ponseti method – a force is applied opposite to the direction of the deformity using a three-point system (one push at the apex, two counter-holds at the ends). The difference: a cast only holds the position after each manipulation, whereas the orthosis can keep applying a moderate, continuous force all night while the child’s muscles are relaxed.
How it works: initial assessment (age, severity, stiffness, ankle range) → each night the orthosis holds the foot slightly more corrected than the child’s own position, at a level the child tolerates → as the foot softens, the orthotist tightens the straps one notch or adjusts the brace → once the foot is straight, night-time wear continues to maintain the result. During the day the child moves freely.
| Component of the deformity | Direction of the corrective force |
|---|---|
| Cavus | Support the first metatarsal, bring the arch back to normal |
| Adductus | Push the foot into abduction, with counter-pressure on the lateral head of the talus |
| Heel varus | Hold the heel neutral to slight valgus |
| Equinus | Hold the ankle at 90° or more; a diagonal strap locks the heel down |
Six steps to put on the night orthosis
Strap tension is adjusted for each child: young children’s tissues soften faster; stiff, severe feet need smaller steps over a longer time; too much tension causes pain, poor sleep, the child pulling the brace off and red skin – a moderate force worn all night works better.
Comparing the three approaches
| Criterion | Ponseti casting | Foot abduction brace (bar) | Night-time orthosis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Initial correction | Maintain correction after casting | Gradual correction and maintenance |
| How force is applied | Weekly manipulation, cast holds the position | Holds the foot externally rotated on a bar | Moderate, continuous force all night |
| Adjusting the force | At each cast change (about weekly) | Fixed by the angle on the bar | Straps tightened notch by notch as tolerated |
| Wearing time | Continuous, about 2 months | 23 h/day for 3 months, then nights until 4–5 years | At night, during sleep |
| Holding the ankle at 90° | Yes, in the post-tenotomy cast | Depends on well-fitting shoes; heel slips easily | Diagonal heel-lock strap plus leg shell |
| Effect on knee and hip | Knee flexed in the cast | Bar transmits rotation to knee and hip | Separate brace for each leg |
| Who it is for | Infants, ideally under 1–2 years | After Ponseti casting | Relapse, incomplete correction, late presentation |
| Evidence | Extensive, gold standard | Many studies on compliance and relapse | New method, data being collected |
Level of evidence: the principle of opposing forces is an established foundation of orthotics; this particular night-orthosis design is a new method of the clinic with no published study yet. Case-by-case follow-up is being recorded and will be updated on this page.
7. Advice for parents
- During casting: check the toes daily (pink, warm, moving); blue, cold, very swollen toes or toes slipping back into the cast – call the doctor at once. A loose, slipping, cracked, wet or smelly cast – get it checked, do not wait for the next appointment.
- With the foot abduction brace: almost full-time for the first 3 months, then during night and day naps; press the heel down into the shoe before fastening; after removal, check that the heel has marked the sole.
- Red marks on the skin that do not fade within about 1 hour of removing the brace – contact the orthotics clinic.
- Return early if the foot is hard to lift up, the heel turns inwards, the child walks on the outer edge of the foot, or the knees and feet turn out too much when walking.
- If your child has relapsed or cannot tolerate the brace: do not wait – repeat casting and a suitable orthosis are the key steps to avoid surgery.
If your child’s clubfoot has relapsed, is not fully corrected or was never treated, contact us for an examination, foot assessment and advice on the right orthosis: +84 985 211 888 (phone / Zalo).
References
- Grin L, van Oorschot L, Vanwanseele B, et al. Kinematic gait impairments in children with clubfeet treated by the Ponseti method: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Children. 2023;10(5):785. PMID: 37238333.
- Karol LA, Jeans K, ElHawary R. Gait analysis after initial nonoperative treatment for clubfeet: intermediate term followup at age 5. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2009;467(5):1206–1213. PMID: 19159114.
- The association between idiopathic clubfoot and increased internal hip rotation. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2009;467(5):1231–1237. PMID: 19229661.
- Complications associated with Ponseti serial casting and surgical correction via soft tissue release. J Med Assoc Thai. 2016;99(11):1192–1197. PMID: 29901930.
- Flatfoot in the contralateral foot in patients with unilateral idiopathic clubfoot treated using the foot abduction brace. Medicine (Baltimore). 2017;96(35):e7937. PMID: 28858119.
- Foot abduction brace in the Ponseti method: torsional deformities and compliance. J Pediatr Orthop. 2007;27(6):712–716. PMID: 17717477.
- Relapse following use of Ponseti method in idiopathic clubfoot. J Child Orthop. 2018;12(6):566–574. PMID: 30607203.
- Shabtai L, Segev E, Yavor A, Wientroub S, Hemo Y. Prolonged use of foot abduction brace reduces the rate of surgery in Ponseti-treated idiopathic club feet. J Child Orthop. 2015;9(3):177–182. PMID: 26091918.
- Ponseti method after walking age – a multi-centric study of 429 feet. Iowa Orthop J. 2020;40(2):1–12. PMID: 33633502.
- The Ponseti method of clubfoot treatment in walking age children: a study of 56 children from 1 to 10 years of age. J Pediatr Orthop B. 2019;28(2):159–166. PMID: 30312250.
- Graf A, Hassani S, Krzak J, et al. The recurrent clubfoot: can gait analysis help us make better preoperative decisions? Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2009;467(5):1214–1222. PMID: 19093158.
- Lower extremity characteristics in recurrent clubfoot: clinical and gait analysis findings. Gait Posture. 2020;75:85–92. PMID: 31627119.
- Anatomical structures responsible for CTEV relapse after Ponseti treatment. Children. 2022;9(5):581. PMID: 35626758.
- Desai L, Oprescu F, DiMeo A, Morcuende JA. Bracing in the treatment of children with clubfoot: past, present, and future. Iowa Orthop J. 2010;30:15–23. PMID: 21045966.
- Janicki JA, Wright JG, Weir S, Narayanan UG. A comparison of ankle foot orthoses with foot abduction orthoses to prevent recurrence following correction of idiopathic clubfoot by the Ponseti method. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 2011;93(5):700–704. PMID: 21511939.
- Farrar EJ, et al. Two-year retrospective cohort results on use of a dynamic unilateral brace for treatment of clubfoot. J Rehabil Assist Technol Eng. 2022;9. PMID: 35845117.
- Is unilateral lower leg orthosis with a circular foot unit in the treatment of idiopathic clubfeet a reasonable bracing alternative in the Ponseti method? BMC Musculoskelet Disord. 2018;19(1):229. PMID: 30021573.
Related solutions
Answering Common Questions About Scoliosis
Answers to parents' most common questions about scoliosis bracing: when one or two braces are needed, why braces must be replaced periodically, and why wear continues even after the spine straightens.
Answering Common Questions About Scoliosis
How Orthotic Bracing Is Used to Treat Scoliosis
An overview of scoliosis — causes, warning signs, and health risks — and why orthotic bracing combined with physical therapy is today's safest, most effective treatment.
How Orthotic Bracing Is Used to Treat Scoliosis
An Overview of Custom Orthotic Insoles for Flat Feet
Causes, benefits, and the treatment process for flat feet using custom orthotic insoles — plus notes on cost and when this approach is truly appropriate.
An Overview of Custom Orthotic Insoles for Flat FeetDo you or a loved one need advice?
Book an in-person assessment in Hanoi or send your file for a remote consultation. We reply within 24 hours.